WLTP vs NEDC Comparison
How the transition from NEDC to WLTP test standards affects your VRT calculation, including CO2 differences, band shifts, and which standard applies to your vehicle.
Key Takeaways
- WLTP produces 10 — 30% higher CO2 figures than NEDC for the same vehicle
- Higher CO2 can push vehicles into higher VRT bands, increasing registration tax
- Vehicles registered before 1 September 2018 use NEDC; after use WLTP
- You must use the official figure from the Certificate of Conformity — you cannot choose
- The band shift can add €500 — €3,000+ to VRT for vehicles near band boundaries
What Is NEDC?
The New European Driving Cycle (NEDC) was the standard method for measuring vehicle emissions and fuel economy in Europe from 1970 until it was phased out in 2017. The test was conducted on a rolling road dynamometer in a controlled laboratory environment, following a predetermined driving pattern that included urban and extra-urban phases.
The NEDC test was widely criticised for being unrealistic. The driving pattern was smooth and predictable, with gentle acceleration, no real-world variables like wind resistance, road gradient, or air conditioning usage, and the test speeds were lower than typical motorway driving. As a result, NEDC figures consistently underestimated real-world fuel consumption and CO2 emissions.
For VRT purposes, the NEDC CO2 figure was used to determine the VRT band for vehicles registered before the WLTP transition. These figures are still relevant for older imported vehicles, and Revenue continues to accept NEDC figures for vehicles that were originally type-approved under that standard.
The NEDC test cycle lasted approximately 1,180 seconds (about 20 minutes) and covered a distance of approximately 11 kilometres. The maximum speed was 120 km/h, and the average speed was only 34 km/h. The test included a cold start, four repeated urban cycles, and one extra-urban cycle. The controlled conditions and gentle driving pattern meant that vehicles consistently achieved better results than they would in real-world driving.
What Is WLTP?
The Worldwide Harmonised Light Vehicles Test Procedure (WLTP) replaced NEDC as the standard emissions test in Europe from September 2017 (initially for new type approvals) and September 2018 (for all new registrations). WLTP was developed by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) to provide a more realistic and globally harmonised test standard.
WLTP addresses many of the criticisms of NEDC. The test cycle is longer (1,800 seconds versus 1,180 seconds), covers more distance (approximately 23 kilometres versus 11 kilometres), includes higher speeds (up to 131 km/h versus 120 km/h), and incorporates more dynamic driving with harder acceleration and deceleration. The test also accounts for vehicle weight, tyre type, and aerodynamic properties more accurately.
The result is that WLTP figures are consistently higher than NEDC figures for the same vehicle. The increase varies by vehicle type and powertrain, but the typical range is 10 — 30% higher CO2 under WLTP. Some vehicles, particularly those with stop-start systems and efficient aerodynamics, may show smaller increases, while performance vehicles and SUVs may show larger increases.
For VRT purposes, the WLTP CO2 figure determines the VRT band for vehicles registered from September 2018 onwards. Revenue uses the WLTP figure from the Certificate of Conformity, and importers cannot choose the NEDC figure even if both are available.
CO2 Differences: NEDC vs WLTP
To understand the real-world impact on VRT, here are typical CO2 differences for popular imported vehicle models:
| Vehicle Model | NEDC CO2 | WLTP CO2 | Increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volkswagen Golf 1.6 TDI | 99 g/km | 115 g/km | +16% |
| BMW 320d | 102 g/km | 118 g/km | +16% |
| Mercedes C220d | 105 g/km | 123 g/km | +17% |
| Audi A4 2.0 TDI | 108 g/km | 127 g/km | +18% |
| Toyota RAV4 Hybrid | 100 g/km | 118 g/km | +18% |
| Hyundai Tucson 1.6 CRDi | 115 g/km | 139 g/km | +21% |
| Volvo XC60 D4 | 120 g/km | 148 g/km | +23% |
| BMW X5 xDrive30d | 140 g/km | 178 g/km | +27% |
The pattern is clear: WLTP figures are consistently higher than NEDC, with larger vehicles and SUVs showing bigger increases. This is because the WLTP test more accurately captures the aerodynamic drag, weight, and tyre resistance of larger vehicles, which the NEDC test underestimated.
The VRT impact of these increases depends on where the vehicle sits relative to the band boundaries. A vehicle that shifts from Band C (111 — 140 g/km, 15.6%) to Band D (141 — 155 g/km, 20.1%) under WLTP faces a 4.5 percentage point increase in the VRT rate. On a €30,000 OMSP, that translates to an additional €1,350 in base VRT.
VRT Band Shifts: How WLTP Changes Your Tax
The most significant impact of the NEDC to WLTP transition is band shifting. When a vehicle’s CO2 figure increases under WLTP, it can move from one VRT band to a higher one, resulting in a higher tax rate. Here are the most common band shifts observed in practice:
| Common NEDC → WLTP Shift | Band Change | Rate Increase | VRT Impact (€30k OMSP) |
|---|---|---|---|
| B → C (61-110 to 111-140) | 10.1% → 15.6% | +5.5% | +€1,650 |
| C → D (111-140 to 141-155) | 15.6% → 20.1% | +4.5% | +€1,350 |
| D → E (141-155 to 156-170) | 20.1% → 24.6% | +4.5% | +€1,350 |
| E → F (156-170 to 171-190) | 24.6% → 29.1% | +4.5% | +€1,350 |
| F → G (171-190 to 191-225) | 29.1% → 34.6% | +5.5% | +€1,650 |
The financial impact of a band shift is significant. A vehicle that crosses even one band boundary under WLTP faces an additional €1,350 — €1,650 in base VRT on a €30,000 OMSP. On higher-value vehicles, the impact is proportionally larger. For a €50,000 OMSP vehicle, a single band shift adds €2,250 — €2,750 in VRT.
The vehicles most affected by band shifting are those that sit close to band boundaries under NEDC. A car with 108 g/km NEDC CO2 (comfortably in Band B at 61 — 110) might shift to 127 g/km under WLTP, pushing it into Band C. The 28 g/km increase is enough to cross the boundary, and the tax consequence is real.
Which Standard Applies to Your Vehicle?
Revenue uses the test standard that corresponds to the vehicle’s date of first registration. The key date is 1 September 2018:
| Registration Date | Test Standard | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Before 1 September 2017 | NEDC | NEDC-only type approval. Use NEDC figures. |
| 1 September 2017 — 31 August 2018 | NEDC or WLTP | Transition period. Check Certificate of Conformity for which figure is provided. |
| From 1 September 2018 | WLTP | All new registrations must use WLTP. Revenue uses WLTP figure. |
During the transition period (September 2017 — August 2018), some vehicles were type-approved under both NEDC and WLTP. In these cases, Revenue uses the WLTP figure if it is available on the Certificate of Conformity. If only the NEDC figure is provided, that figure is used.
You cannot choose the more favourable standard. Revenue will use the official figure from the Certificate of Conformity that corresponds to the vehicle’s type approval and registration date. Attempting to use the wrong figure can result in a reassessment, penalties, and interest charges.
Worked Example: Band Shift Impact
Let us compare the VRT for a Volkswagen Golf 2.0 TDI under both test standards to see the real financial impact of the NEDC to WLTP transition.
Under NEDC (2017 model, registered August 2018)
OMSP: €22,000 | NEDC CO2: 105 g/km (Band B, 10.1%) | Age: 4 years
Step 1: Base VRT = €22,000 × 10.1% = €2,222
Step 2: Age reduction (4 years) = 30% = €667
Step 3: Adjusted VRT = €2,222 ‒ €667 = €1,555
Under WLTP (2019 model, registered September 2018)
OMSP: €23,000 | WLTP CO2: 126 g/km (Band C, 15.6%) | Age: 4 years
Step 1: Base VRT = €23,000 × 15.6% = €3,588
Step 2: Age reduction (4 years) = 30% = €1,076
Step 3: Adjusted VRT = €3,588 ‒ €1,076 = €2,512
WLTP increase: €957 — The WLTP-transitioned vehicle pays nearly €1,000 more in VRT despite being only marginally newer and having a similar engine. The band shift from B to C is the primary driver, combined with a slightly higher OMSP.
Implications for Importers
The NEDC to WLTP transition has significant implications for Irish car importers:
Older imports may be cheaper: Vehicles registered before September 2018 with NEDC figures can have lower VRT than newer identical models tested under WLTP. This creates a financial incentive to import slightly older vehicles, though this must be balanced against the age depreciation factor.
Comparing like-for-like: When comparing vehicles from different model years, make sure you are comparing the same test standard. A 2017 model with 105 g/km NEDC is not directly comparable to a 2019 model with 126 g/km WLTP, even though they may have the same engine.
Certificate of Conformity is critical: Always check the Certificate of Conformity for the official CO2 figure and the test standard used. This is the figure Revenue will use, and it determines your VRT band and tax liability.
Some manufacturers have redesigned engines: In response to WLTP, some manufacturers have updated their engines to achieve lower CO2 under the new test. This means some post-WLTP vehicles may have similar or even lower CO2 than their pre-WLTP predecessors, despite the more demanding test. These engines are worth seeking out for VRT purposes.
Key Takeaways
1. WLTP produces higher CO2 figures — Typically 10 — 30% higher than NEDC for the same vehicle. This is because WLTP is a more realistic and demanding test.
2. Band shifts increase VRT — Vehicles near band boundaries under NEDC can shift to higher bands under WLTP, adding €500 — €3,000+ to the VRT bill.
3. The applicable standard depends on registration date — Before September 2018: NEDC. After September 2018: WLTP. You cannot choose.
4. Check the Certificate of Conformity — This document contains the official CO2 figure and test standard that Revenue will use for your VRT calculation.
5. Pre-WLTP imports can save money — Older vehicles with NEDC figures may have lower VRT than newer models tested under WLTP, even if the engines are identical.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between WLTP and NEDC for VRT?
NEDC was the older test standard that produced lower CO2 figures. WLTP is the newer, more realistic standard that produces higher CO2 figures (typically 10 — 30% higher). Revenue uses the standard that corresponds to the vehicle’s date of first registration.
Which test standard does my car use for VRT?
Vehicles first registered before 1 September 2018 generally use NEDC figures. Vehicles registered from 1 September 2018 onwards use WLTP figures. Check your Certificate of Conformity for the official figure and test standard.
Does WLTP increase VRT costs?
Yes, typically. WLTP produces higher CO2 figures, which can push vehicles into higher VRT bands. The increase varies by vehicle but is commonly 10 — 30% higher CO2, which can add €500 — €3,000+ to the VRT bill depending on the vehicle’s OMSP and band shift.
Can I use the NEDC figure if my car was tested under both standards?
No. If your vehicle has a WLTP figure on its Certificate of Conformity, Revenue will use that figure. You cannot choose the NEDC figure even if it is lower. During the transition period (September 2017 — August 2018), check which figure appears on your CoC.
Related Calculators and Guides
About the Author
Sarah Murphy is an automotive import specialist with over 10 years of experience helping Irish car importers navigate VRT, customs, and vehicle registration. She has assisted thousands of importers with accurate VRT estimates and has been featured in Irish motoring publications.
Questions? Contact the VRT Calculator team for expert advice on vehicle registration tax in Ireland.